Skip to main content
Senate Session 2024/2025 55 speeches

June 4, 2025

Official Hansard Report - Senate

Download PDF transcript

Session Summary

Simplified for You

The Senate reviewed the budget for the newly combined Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport, with Junior Minister Fubler presenting a total allocation of $34.1 million for the ministry headquarters. The session focused heavily on tourism funding, with the BTA receiving $15.5 million (a $540,000 decrease from last year) and the Airport Authority getting $14.9 million. Opposition senators questioned tourism performance metrics, asking for comparisons to pre-COVID numbers and details about vacation rental inspections.

Chamber Senate
Date Jun 4, 2025
Session 2024/2025
Transcript View PDF
Speakers 1
Speeches 55

Key Topics

Budget review for the Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport (2025/26)Funding for the Bermuda Tourism Authority ($15.5 million) and Bermuda Airport Authority ($14.9 million)Department of Sport and Recreation programs including summer camps and elite athlete supportTourism performance metrics and vacation rental/hotel inspectionsInfrastructure projects including King's Wharf Pier extension

Bills & Motions

Appropriation Act 2025 - under consideration in Committee of the Whole Senate for budget review
Budget estimates for Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport (Heads 71, 20, 30, 34, and 35) - being debated

Notable Moments

Junior Minister Fubler noted that 2024 saw tourism growth with 743,000 total visitors and air arrivals up 9.6%
Opposition Leader Jones pressed for more detailed tourism performance data compared to pre-COVID levels and other Caribbean destinations
The Camp Connect summer program served 2,773 children in 2024, a 63% increase from the previous year

Debate Transcript

55 speeches from 1 speaker
The Chairman Chairman Senators, w e are now in Committee of the Whole [Senate] for further consideration of the Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure for the year 2025/26. [The Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport] Heads 71, 20, 30, 34, and 35 are now to be debated. I call on the …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, [Junior] Minister Fubler. Sen. Mischa Fubler: Am I good to proceed?
The Chairman Chairman Yes, please proceed. MINISTRY OF TOURISM AND TRANSPORT, CULTURE AND SPORT Sen. Mischa Fubler: Madam Chairman, I move that the Committee do now undertake consideration of Head 71, Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport [Headquarters] ; Head 20, Sport and Recreation; Head 30, Marine and Ports; Head 34, …
The Chairman Chairman Yes, thank you, Junior Minister Senator Fubler. ANNOUNCEMENT BY THE CHAIRMAN SENATE VISITOR
The Chairman Chairman I would like to acknowledge in the Chamber Ms. Carlita O’Brien, Acting Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport. [Committee of Supply, continuing]
The Chairman Chairman Would any Senator like to speak on the heads that were just presented? Senator Foley, I acknowledge your hand. Thank you. Please proceed. Sen. Maurice Foley: Thank you, Madam Chairman. I thank the Junior Minister, [Senator] Fubler, for being very thorough in his brief. I certainly had a lot of …
The Chairman Chairman Junior Minister Fubler, would you like to— Sen. Mischa Fubler: Let’s collect all of the questions for the first few heads we have covered and then I will endeavour to answer those. Sen. Maurice Foley: Sure. Sure.
The Chairman Chairman Thank you. Please continue, Senator Foley. Sen. Maurice Foley: Okay, so that was the first question. And, you mentioned regarding social media, approximately five million views. I don’t see where I can reference that. But you mentioned about five million views on I believe the BTA website. Is there more …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Foley. Do any other Senators have questions? Thank you, Senate Opposition Leader Jones. Sen. Marcus Jones: Good morning, Madam Chairman. Good morning to my colleagues here in the Senate. And good morning to the listening audience. I do thank the Junior Minister for bringing that brief. I …
The Chairman Chairman Excuse me, Senate Leader Jones, can I just ask that you direct your questions specifically to the line items of the heads that were raised? Sen. Marcus Jones: I am on [page] C -20 which is still under Head 71. It is closely connected to that head. So, I appreciate, …
The Chairman Chairman Yes, Madam Attorney General , Senator Wilkerson. POINT OF ORDER Sen. The Hon. Kim Wilkerson: In this Budget Debate the Leader of the Senate is surmising without facts or evidence. And I do not think this is the place for such. And I am speaking specifically about . . . …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Wilkerson, Attorney General. Senator Jones, can you please direct your questions specifically to the heads that were raised? So, I have noted . . . and I have had a little bit of a difficult time keeping track. I have noted two questions. Do you have any …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you. Sen. Marcus Jones: And I would have to differ with Madam Attorney General. I have indicated which performance measures I am referring to , and most specifically vacation rental properties inspected and licensed. I think it is a fair question to ask how many of those vacation rental …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senate [Opposition] Leader Jones. Would any other . . . Thank you. I acknowledge your hand, Senator Cunningham, please proceed. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Thank you, Madam Chairman. Just two, hopefully short questions. But kind of cross -Ministry. One is, and I was delighted to hear you say that …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Cunningham. Are there any further questions from Senators on the heads raised? Thank you. Senator Fubler, I will return this to you. Sen. Mischa Fubler: Thank you, Madam Chairman. 228 4 June 2025 Official Hansard Report Bermuda Senate And as I mentioned, I collected the questions and …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Junior Minister, Senator Fubler. I would just like to do a time check. It is 11:37. As you are aware, we are due to finish debating these heads at 12:10 and we still have one head left to do. So, just for all Senators to be cognisant of …
The Chairman Chairman I also would like to acknowledge Mr. Mannard Packwood, Ministry Controller for Tourism and Transport, Culture and Sport, who is in the Cham-ber. [Committee of Supply, continuing]
The Chairman Chairman Would any Senators like to speak to the heads? Senator Foley. Bermuda Senate Sen. Maurice Foley: Thank you, Madam Chairman, and thank you Junior Minister Fubler for again providing such detail to your brief. A couple of questions did pop up. [One was] regarding [page] B -244 under insurance, under …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Foley, Would any other Senators like to speak to the heads raised? Senator Fubler, please continue with Head 35. HEAD 35 —DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION Sen. Mischa Fubler: Thank you. And so, our final head for the Ministry is Head 35, Department of Public Transportation, which is …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Junior Minister, Senator Fubler, for your explanation and presentation this morning. I will invite Senators to raise any comments they have about Head 35. I will note that the time is now 11:55, which means that we have 15 minutes left for these questions, and then also responses …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Foley. I will invite any further comments on this h ead. Senators? No. Senator Cunningham, thank you. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Thank you, Madam Chairman. I am just wondering what the definition is of a serious vehicle incident on page B -255 and the performance measures for the …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Cunningham. Would any other Senators like to speak to any of the heads raised in this section? Junior Minister Fubler, I return it to you, thank you. Sen. Mischa Fubler: Thank you, very much. So, starting back at the top now with Head 71, I received questions …
The Chairman Chairman Junior Minister, Senator Fubler, we are out of time. Unfortunately , we did not get to all of the very good questions. Hopefully that discussion can continue between the Opposition and the Government at some other date. Junior Minister, Senator Fubler, would you like to move that these heads be …
The Chairman Chairman Hearing no objection, it has been moved that [the Ministry of Tourism and Transport, Cul-ture and Sport,] Heads 71, 20, 30, 24, and 35 be approved. Is there any objection to that motion? No objection. Then it is agreed to. Thank you. 238 4 June 2025 Official Hansard Report B …
The Chairman Chairman Senators, it is now 12:10. I have spoken to the Junior Minister, Senator Lauren Bell, who has indicated that she would like to begin to present after lunch. So, if we can rise now, and reconvene at 1:45 pm. Thank you. Proceedings in Committee suspended at 12:1 0 pm Proceedings …
The Chairman Chairman Welcome back, Senators. Senators, we continue to be in Committee of the whole [Senate] for further consideration of the Esti-mates of Revenue and Expenditure for the year 2025/26, Heads 21, 22, 24, 91, 16 and 17. [These] will be presented by Junior Minister Senator Lauren Bell and to be debated. …
The Chairman Chairman Please proceed. HEAD 21—M INISTRY OF HEALTH HEADQUARTERS Sen. Lauren Bell: Thank you. Madam Chairman, the Ministry of Health has been al-lotted a total of $245,440,000 for the fiscal year 2025/26 for the heads of its Headquarters, the Department of Health, Hospitals and Health Insurance Department. Today I am pleased …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Bell. I just wanted to make a quick note. I should have said this initially. We started at 1:48 pm and we have three hours on this head. So, we will be finishing at 4:48 pm. Thank you. Grants Administration Sen. Lauren Bell: Thank you, Madam Chairman. …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Junior Minister, Senator Bell. I would just like to have a time check. The time is currently 3:23 pm and we are due to finish the Health [Ministry] debate at 4:48 pm. You may continue. Sen. Lauren Bell: Thank you, Madam Chairman. HEAD 24 —HOSPITALS Sen. Lauren Bell: …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Junior Minister Bell, Senator Bell. Do you have any . . . did you receive any questions prior to today's presentation that you would like to address? Sen. Lauren Bell: Yes, I can report that I received three questions from the Opposition. Those questions were answered in the …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Wight. Senator Bell, how do you wish to proceed? Collect all the questions, including Senator Wight's . . . or answer Senator Wight’s questions now? Sen. Lauren Bell: Correct, Chairman. That's my preference.
The Chairman Chairman Okay, thank you. Would any other Senator like to comment on the heads raised? Senator Cunningham. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Thank you, Madam Chairman. So, I'm asking all my questions, and then —
The Chairman Chairman Yes, Senator Cunningham. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Yes, so I can confirm that a lot of the pre- posed questions were covered in the brief. The main one asked about the anticipated total cost of implementing Universal Health Care, I did hear her say there is no single price tag. So, …
The Chairman Chairman Excuse me, Senator Cunningham, just a time check. There are 15 minutes left to discuss this. Thank you. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Well, I will leave hospitals then because my colleague in the House, in the other place, sorry, had limited time on that, but she was able to ask . …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Cunningham. Do any of the other Senators wish to speak on the heads raised? Thank you, Senator Bell. Back to you to respond. Thank you to the questions raised. Sen. Lauren Bell: Thank you, Madam Chairman. A question from Senator Cunningham was, What were the main priorities …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you. Sen. Lauren Bell: You are welcome. The question was posed by the Senator regarding the increased funding of approximately $22 million. And he queried what were the three greatest needs for the hospital in 2025/26. The net increase to the BHB was $4.5 million when all the grants …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Junior Minister, Senator Bell. That is all the time that we have to debate these heads today. Senator Wight and Senator Cunningham, thank you for your concise and clear questions and Senator Bell for your answers that were also concise and clear. Do you wish to move these …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senators. Are there any objections to moving these heads? None being heard. The heads are so moved. Thank you, Senator. [Motion carried: The Ministry of Health, Heads 21, 22, 24 and 91 were approved and stand part of the Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure for the year 2025/26.]
The Chairman Chairman I would like to invite my colleague Independent Senator John Wight to assume the Chairman position for the following debate. [Sen. John Wight, Chairman] MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
The Chairman Chairman Senators, we are now in Committee of the whole [Senate] for further consideration of the Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure for the year 2025/26. The heads to be debated now under the Education Ministry are Head 16, which can be found on page B -132 regar ding the Ministry of …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Minister. Please proceed. Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Colleagues, I would like to first thank the former Minister of Education, my predecessor the Honourable Diallo V. Rabain, now Minister for the Cabinet Office and Digital Innovation who graciously presented the budget for the Ministry …
The Chairman Chairman Yes, Minister. It's ten after six, so we have exactly 30 minutes remaining on your heads. Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: Mr. Chair man, I am going to try and move along so that we can leave a bit of time. I do still have quite a bit of interesting …
The Chairman Chairman Minister, I just realised that I short - changed you by 10 minutes before when I gave you the time check, so you actually have 35 minutes left now. Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: Okay. [Laughter]
The Chairman Chairman You actually have 35 minutes left now. Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you for that.
The Chairman Chairman My addition wasn't very good. Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: Because I was just assessing. What can I cut? But, yes . . . okay. No worries. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. 1709 —Curriculum and Assessment 276 4 June 2025 Official Hansard Report Bermuda Senate Sen. the Hon. Crystal …
The Chairman Chairman Very good, Minister. Thank you very much for that fulsome brief. Would any Senator who advanced the questions care to ask them at this time? Senator Cunningham. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Fi rst of all, I would just like to thank the new Honourable Minister of Education. …
The Chairman Chairman We certainly do have a little bit of time left, I guess . . . we have 11 minutes left. Senator Tannock , you have your hand up. Would you like to ask a question? Sen. Tawana Tannock: Yes, thank you. Thank you, [Mr. Chairman] . Minister, my first question …
The Chairman Chairman Please do, Senator Tannock, yes. Sen. Tawana Tannock: Thank you. And so then . . . I am going to Head 17, on page B-145, I just wanted some clarity, and this is sort of the bulk of questions, right? So, if we take the primary schools, special schools, middle …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Senator Tannock, for those questions. Senator Cunningham, over to you for your questions. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Thank you, and time remaining?
The Chairman Chairman Time remaining—eight minutes. Sen. Victoria Cunningham: Okay, thank you. So, a question overall on education reform. Obviously, there must have been some kind of projections done up front . But I am just wondering if the, I guess, the G overnment or the R eform Unit or the Ministry has …
The Chairman Chairman Just as a time . . . I'm sorry, Senator Cunningham. I'm just going to say with a time check, we have three minutes left. So, I think we will — Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: So, I can . . . I do have answers to some of the …
The Chairman Chairman Minister, I think we're actually at our 6:51 pm . . . so we are one minute over with that answer. So , I think it is time to move the heads. So over to you. Sen. the Hon. Crystal Caesar: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I do undertake to …
The Chairman Chairman Thank you, Minister. It has been moved that H eads 16 and 17 be approved. Is there any objection to that motion? Hearing no objection, we can confirm that those heads are now moved. Thank you, Minister. [Motion carried: The Ministry of Education, Heads 16 and 17 were approved and …
The Chairman Chairman It has been moved that the C ommittee rise, report progress and ask for leave to sit again. Is there any objection to that motion? Hearing none, no objection. It's all agreed to. [Motion carried: The Committee of Supply rose and reported progress and asked for leave to sit again.]
The Chairman Chairman Thank you very much, Minister. And thank you very much to all Senators who asked questions. Much appreciated. And I now have the great pleasure for the third day in a row in giving my seat back to Madam President so she can continue with the Senate's business. Thank you. …
Hansard Transcript Open in new tab